Classic theism teaches that god is impassible not subject to suffering, pain, or the ebb and flow of involuntary passions. Pdf the impassibility of god and the problem of evil researchgate. A totally impassive god would be a horror, and not the god of calvary at all. God does not in any sense control the actions of intelligent creatures, but foreknows those actions comprehensively. More specifically, it is the doctrine that god does not experience pain or pleasure due to the actions of others. Notwithstanding these distinctions, the love of god is free, infinite. The doctrine of impassibility cannot be modified or rejected without a proportionate alteration to the entire doctrine of the essence and attributes of god. The impassibility of god classic christian orthodoxy teaches that god is impassible that is, not subject to suffering, pain, or involuntary passions. T his is a relatively short book in which to attempt a reinterpretation of the important concept of divine impassibility in patristic thoughtparticularly since, as well as charting the course of debate on this topic, the book has the goal of disproving what it calls the theory of theologys fall into hellenistic philosophy. The immutability and impassibility of god the gospel. The impassibility of god microform a survey of christian. In the words of the westminster confession of faith, god is without body, parts, or passions, immutable.
I know mine, so i only introduce the impassibility of god for discussion. Read god is impassible and impassioned online by rob lister and. This attribute, if true, would mean that god does not have passions or emotions, but is impassible, not subject to passions. The impassible god of the bible wesley hill first things. Aquinas believed that the emotional side of impassibility is a minor detail in. The beauty of the impassible god or, is god an emotional. The article discusses aquinass views on god s impassibility, immutability, and eternality. The greek word apathes describes a god without pain or pleasure. This spectrum multiview volume brings together four theologians who make a case for their own viewranging from a traditional affirmation of divine impassibility the idea that god does not suffer to the position that god is necessarily and intimately affected by creationand then each contributor responds to the others views. They hold that god is distant and immune from the winds of emotion that. The suffering of the impassible god provides a major reconsideration of the notion of divine impassibility in patristic thought. Part v chapter offers an overview of the doctrine of divine impassibility as contained in the second london confession of faith 167789. Aquinas argued that god has no passions and god s perfection rules out his negative emotions, such as sorrow, fear, envy, or anger.
Therefore, impassibility guarantees that god s love could not be more infinite in its loveliness. Impassibility definition of impassibility by the free dictionary. If, therefore, we can learn to think of the chosenness of god s grief and pain as the essence of his impassibility, socalled, we will do well. These concern whether god s nature is to be understood in terms of god s being absolute, immutable, and impassible, or as subject who engages in free actions. Read god is impassible and impassioned by rob lister,bruce a. Brasnett in his book the suffering of the impassible god, have. The view that god is in no way affected by creatures is called the impassibility of god. Heres an excellent address on god without passions delivered by pastor gavin beers, a pastor in ayr, scotland. A powerful emotion, such as love, joy, hatred, or anger. In this issue, a case is made for divine impassibility, one that refuses to turn god into a victim, or make. Classic christian orthodoxy teaches that god is impassible that is, not subject to suffering, pain, or involuntary passions. To many readers, confessing the impassible god will be a surprising book. This chapter offers answers to the six questions that j.
Surin, the impassibility of god and the problem of evil, sjt 35 1982, p. There is but one only, living, and true god, who is infinite in being and perfection, a most pure spirit, invisible, without body, parts, or passions. For much of church history, these doctrines constituted a theological grammar by which christians were helped to properly locate the creatorcreature distinction. He mentioned that god cannot be angry because he cannot feel sorrow and he cannot be injured. On the one hand the notion of divine passibility would appear to call in question the steadfastness or immutability of god in face of the pressure of. Read unlimited books and audiobooks on the web, ipad. God is impassibly x where x is any appropriate disposition of god for example, joy only if. When theologians speak of god s passibility versus his impassibility, they are referring to his freedom to respond emotionally versus a perceived lack of empathy for his creatures.
Pdf the impassibility of god and the problem of evil. The impassibility of god download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. It articulates and defends the impassibility of god by baptists, taking seriously the statements of baptist confessions of faith of the seventeenth century. It is also stated that since god does not change, he is, therefore, not emotionally affected by what happens in our world.
Pdf according to a certain strand in the orthodox christian theist tradition, gods impassibility is engendered by his immutable nature. The attributes of god cannot be denied or affirmed in isolation. Divine impassibility was thought by medieval christian theologians to be one of the attributes of god. Confessing the impassible god i paul helm confessing the impassible. Paul helm has offered the following philosophical definition of divine impassibility. Impassibility definition of impassibility by the free. More specifically, impassibility means that god does not experience suffering and pain, and thus does not have feelings that are analogous. Theology has no falser idea than that of the impassibility of god. It doesnt answer all the questions, but its an accessible treatment of an important subject. Mozley poses at the end of his influential 1926 book, the impassibility of god.
Not inability or unwillingness to empathize with human pain and grief, either. They propose modern passibilist understandings of god they argue that god can suffer and change or be surprised by his creations. Gods impassibility, immutability, and eternality oxford. However, if i was going to preach about god s love it should be consistent with the doctrine of god s impassibility. The passibility of god religious studies cambridge core. But lately, evangelicals have changed their tune in an attempt to make god far more relational and immanent.
Rather, god is impassible because he is free from the imperfections. Moltmanns trinitarian interpretation of the cross is found in crucified god, pp. It means simply that god s experiences do not come upon him as ours come upon us. It also concerns the relationship between god and people regarding our effect upon god as it relates to his emotions. He contends for a traditional understanding of divine impassibility while contending that god is. For more online resources on various subjects go to online resources. The question whether, in what sense, and under what circumstances suffering may be ascribed to god runs as a golden thread through such major controversies as docetism, patripassianism, arianism, and nestorianism. Moltmanns book is a profound, but somewhat elusive, attempt to make the theology of the cross the central point of the christian faith, and to work out the implications of this theology of the cross for the christian understanding of god.
In order to bear witness to the total truth of god as revealed in jesus christ, t. Not impassivity, unconcern, and impersonal detachment in the face of the creation. The doctrine of divine impassibility has sparked much controversy among modern theologians. Since god is immutable, he must also be impassible. The impassibility of god and the problem of evil article pdf available in scottish journal of theology 3502. Impassibility of god impassibility is that divine attribute whereby god is said not to experience inner emotional changes of state whether enacted freely from within or effected by his relationship to and interaction with human beings and the created order. Rob lister enters this debate in god is impassible and impassioned.
Renihan rbap currently has two books on divine impassibility, god without passions. Click download or read online button to get the impassibility of god book now. The doctrine of the passibility of god has to do with the theology of the suffering of god. The impassibility of god deals with whether or not god can be emotionally affected, either externally or internally by something or someone other than himself. Gods impassibility and feelings reformed answers to. B how can suffering exist when free, morally imperfect. Torrance recognized the need to speak paradoxically when addressing god s impassibility and passibility. To be passible is to be capable of feeling, especially suffering or to be susceptible to emotion. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. It is the doctrine that god does not have passions or emotions. Free grace baptist church confessing the impassible god.
Finally, impassibility provides great hope, for only a god who is not vulnerable to suffering in his divinity is capable of rescuing a world drowning in suffering. Such surprise is due largely to the custom of identifying baptists exclusively with the culture and theology of modern evangelicalism, the temper of mind of which is. So you would find many christians historically who would agree with this view. God, hodge addresses the assertion of the scholastic theologians that god cannot be subject to passivity in any form. It includes such doctrines as god s aseity selfsufficiency, eternity, immutability, impassibility, and simplicity.
1217 1342 692 1021 288 93 1342 1174 600 1245 474 996 692 127 887 1060 653 1339 1380 106 1480 1293 239 381 1183 748 581 352 24 933